Articles Blog

How We Domesticated Cats (Twice)

How We Domesticated Cats (Twice)

When a group of French archaeologists landed
on the island of Cyprus in 2001, they quickly found that they were … outnumbered. Despite having a population of about 1.2 million
people, Cyprus turned out to have an even bigger population of cats. By some estimates, as many as 1.5 million
felines, including both pets and feral cats, roam the country. You can find them practically everywhere! But Cyprus is an island in the Mediterranean,
and, if you’ve ever tried to give a cat a bath, you know most of them aren’t big
fans of water. The closest mainland is Turkey, about 70 kilometers
away! So how did all of those cats get there? Well, those French archaeologists might have
found the answer. While excavating the site of an ancient settlement,
they discovered something quite surprising. It was the grave of a man who was buried alongside
offerings of flint tools, seashells and … an 8 month old cat. Dating to around 9,500 years ago, this burial
represented some of the oldest known evidence of human/cat companionships anywhere in the
world – predating the more well-known love of cats in ancient Egypt by 4,000 years! But when did this close relationship between
humans and cats start? Who were the ancestors of domesticated cats? And how did humans help cats take over Cyprus…and
eventually the world? For that, we can thank the complex process
known as domestication. And yes — even though we let them poop in
our houses and knock stuff off our counters and sometimes pee in the laundry basket for
some reason — we did domesticate them, even though it might not always feel like it. Today’s domesticated cat is its own species,
known as Felis catus. And we can trace its origins to a species
of wild cats called Felis silvestris, which is made up of five different subspecies. Based on studies of the genomes of modern
house cats, one subspecies, called Felis silvestris lybica, is the direct ancestor of all domesticated
cats today. And those wild cats — often referred to as
African wildcats — can still be found across North Africa and Southwest Asia. And as you can tell, these ancestral cats
don’t look very different from their domesticated descendants. They’re slightly larger, and they don’t
have the color variations in their coats that we see in house cats. Instead, they mostly have what are called
mackerel-tabby patterns, with stripes that run perpendicular to their spines. You can even find this same pattern in the
cats depicted in ancient Egyptian artwork. Now, these wild kitties are solitary creatures
that don’t have the same social structure that other animals, like wolves,
do. So scientists think that the domestication
of cats was probably a different process from the domestication of other animals. But unfortunately, the fossil record of African
wildcats isn’t great. Most haven’t been preserved well enough
to be used in genetic analysis, which is partly why it’s been so hard to figure out how
cat domestication actually worked. Some of the oldest known fossils include specimens
from Cyprus that are about 11,000 years old, and others in Turkey from around 10,000 years
ago. So, how did we get from Felis silvestris lybica
to Felis catus? Well, you know how hard it is to get cats
to do stuff. It took a lot of time! And we still don’t know the full picture,
but the first step is understanding the different ways in which animals can be domesticated. A species is considered to be “domesticated”
when it becomes genetically and permanently modified through human-influenced breeding. And it has to be reliant on humans on some
level, like for food and shelter. Or to clean out the litter box. And American archaeologist Dr. Melinda Zeder
has proposed that there are three pathways to domestication: the prey pathway, the directed
pathway, and the commensal pathway. In the prey pathway, wild animals are first
hunted by people. Then, in order to better control the hunts,
people begin to manage herds of the animals, like goats and cattle. This leads to captive breeding and eventually
domestication of the species. With the directed pathway, people use lessons
they learned from previous attempts at domestication, often through the prey pathway. Horses and beasts of burden, like donkeys
and camels, were most likely domesticated this way. We fast-tracked their domestication in order
to harness their abilities to walk long distances and carry heavy loads. And finally, in the commensal pathway, wild
animals are attracted to human settlements by food. They go where the people go, feeding off of
their scraps, or on prey that may have also been drawn to the humans, like mice or rats. And this eventually leads to domestication. This is probably how cats were domesticated. For thousands of years, they stayed close
to human dwellings for food, but weren’t necessarily close to the people themselves. But eventually, people noticed that cats were
actually pretty good at catching the pests that plagued their food stores, and began
to actively entice them to live in their settlements. And we can get glimpses into this process
by studying the remains of ancient kitties. For example, isotopic analysis of cat remains
from 5,600 years ago in northwestern China has revealed trace amounts of millet, a staple
grain in the diet of the human villagers there. This suggests that cats were eating the mice
that were feeding on stored millet, no doubt a useful service for the villagers! And the isotopic data from one cat revealed
a diet that had less meat and more millet than expected, suggesting that it either scavenged
from, or was fed by, the villagers…. Aww! So what did domestication, as a process, do
to change wild cats into house cats? Well, physically, domestication has made house
cats smaller than their ancestors, and resulted in new varieties in coat color and patterning. These included new variations of the tabby
coat, and the introduction of black, orange, and white colors. Most of these coat changes are fairly recent,
and came about as recessive genes in wildcats became more prominent. Then by the 19th century, scientists believe,
people started to selectively breed for more variation in markings and colors. But beyond size and color, domestication really
didn’t change the morphology of cats that much compared to, say, dogs, which have seen
major changes to their whole bodies. This is mostly because of differences in breeding
practices, as different dog breeds were bred for specific purposes. Modern cats also maintain more genetic and
behavioral similarities with their wild ancestors than most other domesticated animals do, including
behaviors related to eating and breeding. This is probably because of interbreeding
between domesticated cats and surrounding wildcat populations. But the thing is, wildcats are actually thought
to have been domesticated twice – once in southwest Asia about 10,000 years ago, and
again in Egypt, about 3,500 years ago! This is based on an analysis of the genome
of modern cats, which suggests that two different source populations contributed to the current
gene pool at two different times. And we’ve also found archaeological evidence
that supports multiple points of domestication. For example, in Egypt, six burials have been
uncovered at the site of Hierakonpolis containing two adult cats and four kittens. And they date to between 3,600 and 3,800 years
ago. Their smaller bones closely match the size
of those in domesticated cats, and one cat’s skeleton even showed healed fractures, suggesting
that it was cared for by its human companions. After about 3,000 years ago in Egypt, we can
see these relationships becoming closer, through art and iconography that show cats alongside
people. And from there, it looks like cats were brought
to Rome by early Greek settlers, as well as through interactions between Rome and Egypt. As civilizations begin to expand around 2,000
years ago, especially within the Roman Empire, cats followed as well. We know ancient Romans kept felines as pets,
based on various artworks,like mosaics, that show cats in more domestic settings, often
hunting prey. Roman cats were most likely adopted into households
to catch rodents and other pests – much like they did in the early stages of domestication. But none of this actually tells us where the
story of cat domestication started: after all If the oldest evidence of domestic cats is on the
island of Cyprus, then who brought cats to Cyprus in the first place? Well, all we know is that, at some point during
the Early Holocene Epoch, possibly 11,000 years ago, people from southwest Asia began
to migrate to Europe — including Cyprus. And they brought with them that subspecies
of cat that was the ancestor of our domesticated cats. And, cats being cats, we ended up with millions
of the little guys In modern day Cyprus, the cat population has
boomed to the point of being considered an infestation. Cats are often seen as vermin, and there have
been many attempts to get a handle on their growing population. Luckily for the feral cats, though, there
are many sanctuaries run by volunteers who try to care for every stray. But it’s not just on this island where cats
have commanded such a presence. Our relationship has been mutually beneficial
enough that domestic cats have truly taken over the world. Today their estimated overall
population of 600 million. Cats have achieved world domination, but if
it wasn’t for us, they might’ve never have left Africa and Asia. We carried them to places they otherwise might
never have seen. So maybe our pet cats should treat us with
a little more respect. Mine could’ve started by not peeing on my
laundry. But I loved him anyway. Big thanks and kitty snuggles to this month’s
Eontologists: Patrick Seifert, Jake Hart, Jon Davison Ng, and Steve! To join the Eonites, go and
pledge your support…like right meow! Kallie asked me to use those exact words! But I also want to thank you for joining me
in the Konstantin Haase Studio. Be sure to subscribe at for
more evolutionary adventures!

100 thoughts on “How We Domesticated Cats (Twice)”

  1. Me and French Archaeologists looking at the same evidence:

    Archaeologists: This cat was buried as a ritual sacrifice when its owner died.

    Me: This human was buried when he couldn't bear living after his kitty-cat died.

  2. a significant evolutionary change in such a relatively short time, just 11 kya, maybe 35
    I thought evolution took 10 or a hundred times that?

  3. Jaw drop Only 600-million cats, but 7-billion humans?!? Guys there aren't enough cats to go around!!! And no one can have mine!

  4. Nope.  Dogs are domesticated.  They love us.  They share in our work & play.  They are part of our families.  Cats just find us a convenient source of food, but otherwise have no use for humans.

  5. My grandfather once splashed some water on ''annoying cat'' at his doorstep. and the next week everyday he found cat-poop next to his door.

  6. Cyprus sounds like they need to spay and neuter their domestic and feral cats. I am sure many of these cats could also be good "therapy" or "support" animals for people in nursing homes, hospitals, and other venues.
    Cats are very observant and curious animals. They saw oppurr-tunities, and took action!

  7. also, I think cats prevented large scale epidemic, like the ones happened during the Dark Ages, when people hunted down cats believing they were evil.

  8. Funny enough just watched an episode similar to this on Sci Show and was hoping the Eons version as well.
    Really though it should be like this. When Dogs domesticated humans followed by Cats domesticating humans twice (Humans never learn after all). We all know the secret age long war in the background between Cats and Dogs. Currently of course its a stalemate, but once Cats gain opposable thumbs its all over…………as shown in Love, Death and Robots!

  9. I’m still confused as to why those fluffy Himalayan cats have those smushed faces.
    And what’s with those cats with no fur?
    They look creepy.

  10. 1. come home from work
    2. watch cat video on the internet
    3. lern interesting things

    Seems like a successful evening to me.

  11. I don't mean to disagree with you but actually was the cat who domesticated humans there were found in a town much like you describe on east of the Nile

  12. Our cats never knocked anything over, nor did the scratch where they were not supposed to, nor do they do any other mess or things… Just the occasional dead bird/mouse/rat at the door.

  13. I know Turks are viewed as the bad guys at the moment, we can appreciate our love of cats. Cats are literally everywhere in Turkey and people tend to care for them (not just Turks, kurds and all the other people in Turkey)

  14. The sad thing about Cyprus is that the population of cats is pretty much guaranteed to have driven many species of endemic birds and rodents, and even smaller reptiles, extinct. Long before anyone thought up science or imagined trying to figure out what lives on the island.

    Domestic cats are one of the agents that have made humans a holocaust on biodiversity wherever they go.

  15. Too much detail packed in this video. It makes for entertaining, but not for learning. Luckily, it’s possible to run it back and stop it. All those captions under the pictures and the maps are useless at this speed.

  16. I think what actually happened is cats domesticated us. Noticing that some early humans will give food to cute and fluffy creatures, the wild cats started to encourage this behaviour by catching vermin. Once they had a grip on the humans, the cats then set about defending themselves from their preditors by encouraging the humans to hunt them. They also encouraged the humans to attact more cat food by building up larger and larger settlements. Lacking disposable thumbs of their own, they had to encourage the humans to develop the key technological advancements, such as the warm sunny spot by the window, radiators and laptops for improved snoozing; cat flaps for enhanced access and egress from their houses; and most importantly, entertainment such as fluff on a piece of string, laser pointers and cardboard boxes.

  17. Twice? I find it hard to believe they were domesticated once. If you just think of Cats as opportunistic assholes, you could argue that they're still feral.

  18. The conundrum is, we think we domesticated cats, while the truth is more that they got us to feed and house them. Who domesticated whom?

  19. How is it that the domestic cat is considered a separate species from it's wild counterpart, whereas dogs and wolves are considered the same species? Just seems like there's a lot more genetic variation between dogs and wolves than between wildcats and domestic cats.

  20. This is totally unrelated to this video, but is there any chance you could make a video about the development of speech in human species? I bet that would be very interesting to a lot of people who watch your videos, even if the fossil evidence about this subject is sparse or hard to interpret.

  21. For some cats especially on urban area, cats not only got domestification but I called it hyper-domestification. The negative effect of this hyper-domestification is the lack of cat ability to prey. Supossedly an animal shouldn't depend on human to get food, they should able to get their food without the human's feeding. Even they are not in jungle there are still smaller animals that cats can prey, not to mention many rats on alley and sewers also insects. But now even there are many small animal cats still have tendency to beg on human for food, oftenly they so thin and malnutried without human feeding. This even effect how cat mothers teach their children. Instead teach their kitten how to catch someday a cat mother bringing his kitten came into my house and begging for food. The kitten was scared of me at that time but as time goes on and she saw her mother got food by begging, she started begging also to me! After saw that her kitten able to beg to human by herself she left her kitten at my house!

  22. I've been looking for this exact video for years to no avail, only getting bits and pieces instead of a comprehensive timeline. I am so glad you made this. Thank you for all your hard work!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *